Welcome to the 500 Spatulas Bake Shop–for all your Greater New York Area baked good needs! Happy to accommodate allergies and special requests. To place an order or get more information, email me at 500spatulas@gmail.com.
Order A Decorate-Your-Own Holiday Cookie Kit today!
Christmas Kit $30 Chanukah Kit $30 Chrismukkah Kit $35
The Christmas and Chanukah kits include 12 holiday cookies, three colors of buttercream, and holiday sprinkles ($30). The Christmukkah kit includes 12 holiday cookies, 4 colors of buttercream and assorted holiday sprinkles ($35). Available all month long with pickup in Manhattan/East 20s (delivery available; subject to an additional fee). Order your kit today!
Exact buttercream colors/sprinkles may vary slightly
We are completely booked January 3 – 13, 2020!
CAKES
“Cartoon Mouse” Inspired Cake Pumpkin Pie Cake Sports Jersey Cake Apple Crisp Cake Paw Patrol Cake Bunny Pull-Apart Cake Banana Nutella S’mores Cake Monster Cake Sprinkle Number Cake Berries n’ Cream Cake Red Velvet Cake Peanut Butter Snickers Avalanche Cake Triple Chocolate Drip Cake Nutella Dream Cake Buttercream Rose Cake Easter Carrot Cake Dairy Free Chocolate Cake Tres Leches Cake Hot Cocoa Cake Triple Chocolate Candy Cake Smash Cake Painted Buttercream Cake Carrot Cake Chocolate Rope Cake Funfetti Bridal Shower Cake Praline King Cake Sprinkle Cake Reeses Peanut Butter Chocolate Cake Cookie Dough Cake Cow Cake Chocolate Oreo Cake Logo Cake GF/Vegan Sheet Cake Buttercream Semi Naked Cake
COOKIES
Turkey Cookies Guitar Cookies Monkey & Banana Cookies Batman Cookies Cartoon Mouse Cookies Pumpkin Sugar Cookies Thanksgiving Cookies Dreidel Cookies Holiday Cookies Gingerbread Men & Women Valentine’s Day Cookies March Madness Cookies Firework Cookies Sugar Cookies Paws Black and Whites Spooky Black & White Cookies Knicks Themed Black & White Cookies Italian Rainbow Cookies Knicks Themed Rainbow Cookies Double Chocolate Monster Cookies Cinnamon Roll Cookies Kitchen Sink Cookies Chewy Banana Oat Cookies Salted Dark Chocolate PB Cookies Chocolate Hazelnut Supremes Chocolate Crinkle Cookies Oreo Cheesecake Swirl Cookies Maple Pecan Brown Sugar Cookies Maple Cinnamon Stars Hamantaschen Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies Traditional Sugar Cookies Palmiers Soft Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies Crispy Chocolate Chip Cookies Nutella Chocolate Chip Cookies S’Mores Cookies Brownie Walnut Chunk Cookies M&M Cookies Funfetti Cookies Almond Joy Macaroons Vegan Twix Bars
CUPCAKES
Spring Bouquet Lemon Cupcakes Yellow Cupcakes with Choc/Vanilla Frosting Spring Flower Cupcakes Paw Patrol Cupcakes Cookies & Cream Cupcakes Chocolate Chocolate Cupcakes Shaun the Sheep Cupcakes Cowboy Cupcakes w/ Chocolate Hats & Boots Funfetti Cupcakes Jungle Cupcakes Cupcake Assortment
MACARONS
All of our macarons are gluten free
Matcha Macarons Cinnamon Macarons Cookie Dough Macarons Coffee Macarons Vanilla Macarons Pistachio Macarons Lemon Macarons French Macarons
BROWNIES & BARS
Flourless Fudgy Brownies Passionfruit Bars Buckeye Brownies S’Mores Cookie Bars Raspberry Crumb Cake Bars Lemon Bars
PIES, CRISPS & CRUMBLES
Peanut Butter Cup Pie Brown Sugar Sweet Potato Pie Banana Cream Pie Maple Pecan Pie Pumpkin Pie Peach Blueberry Pie Flag Berry Pie Apple Hand Pies Whoopie Pies Pecan Pie Caramel Apple Pie Plum Torte Peach Blueberry Crisp Gobbler Sweet Potato Pie Apple Crumble Pie Salted Honey Pie
LOAVES & BREADS
Chocolate Walnut Povitica Triple Chocolate Babka Chocolate Babka Chocolate Chip Banana Zucchini Bread Iced Lemon Loaf Strawberry Banana Bread Marble Pound Cake Pumpkin Spice Babka Chocolate Chip Banana Bread Challah Menorah Challah Challah Round Holiday Challah Pumpkin Challah Raspberry Star Bread Soft Pretzels Cranberry Nut Bread Chocolate Overload Babka Braided Sourdough Pumpkin Danish Loaf Rustic Bread
SWEET CONFECTIONS
Peanut Butter Oreo Bark Eggless Cookie Dough Chocolate Boots & Horseshoes Pecan Gingerbread Fudge Turtle Fudge Oreo Fudge Cake Batter Fudge Gingerbread Swirl Fudge Rocky Road Nutella Fudge
GLUTEN FREE
Chocolate Fudge Cake Buttercream Rose Cake GF/Vegan Chocolate Sheet Cake Flourless Lemon Almond Cake Maple Pecan Pie Flourless Fudgy Brownies Almond Joy Macaroons Coconut Macaroons Chocolate Crinkle Cookies Turtle Fudge French Macarons
Gifts & Events
French Macarons Peanutella Cashew Macademia Nut Funfetti Butter Dipped Pretzels Oreo Truffles
