Bake Shop

Welcome to the 500 Spatulas Bake Shop–for all your Greater New York Area baked good needs! Happy to accommodate allergies and special requests. I also have access to a kosher kitchen if needed. To place an order or get more information, email me at 500spatulas@gmail.com.

Submit Order Request Form

CAKES

: Knicks Jersey Cake

: Peanut Butter Snickers Avalanche Cake

: Buttercream Rose Cake

: Easter Carrot Cake

: Dairy Free Chocolate Cake

: Triple Chocolate Candy Cake

: Hot Cocoa Cake

: Banana Nutella S’Mores Cake

: Chocolate Rope Cake

: Painted Buttercream Cake

: Carrot Cake

: Triple Chocolate Drip Cake

: Reeses Peanut Butter Chocolate Cake

: Oreo Supreme Cake

: Chocolate Fudge Cake

: Praline King Cake

: Buttercream Cake

: Cow Cake

: Flourless Chocolate Cake

: Monster Cake

: Funfetti Pinata Cake

: Funfetti Bridal Shower Cake

: Tres Leches Cake

: Pineapple Carrot Cake

: Cookie Dough Cake

: Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake

: Chocolate Bread Pudding Cake

: Flourless Lemon Almond Cake

: Molten Lava Cakes

: Cherry Clafouti

: Crumb Cake

COOKIES

: Guitar Cookies

: Monkey & Banana Cookies

: Batman Cookies

: March Madness Cookies

: Disney Cookies

: Valentine’s Day Cookies

: Gingerbread Men & Women

: Holiday Cookies

: Pumpkin Sugar Cookies

: Dreidel Cookies

: Spooky Black & White Cookies

: Italian Rainbow Cookies

: Knicks Themed Rainbow Cookies

: Cinnamon Roll Cookies

: Black and Whites

: Knicks Themed Black & White Cookies

: Maple Cinnamon Stars

: Hamantaschen

: Palmiers

: Soft Baked Funfetti Cookies

: Crispy Chocolate Chip Cookies

: Soft Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies

: Salted Dark Chocolate PB Cookies

: Nutella Chocolate Chip Cookies

: Brownie Walnut Chunk Cookies

: Chocolate Crinkle Cookies

: Oreo Cheesecake Swirl Cookies

: Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies

: White Chocolate Pumpkin Snickerdoodles

: Snickerdoodles

: Kitchen Sink Cookies

: Chewy Banana Nut Oat Cookies

: Mandelbrot

: Traditional Sugar Cookies

: Coconut Macaroons

: Almond Joy Macaroons

CUPCAKES

: Spring Bouquet Lemon Cupcakes

: Spring Flower Cupcakes

: Jungle Cupcakes

: Valentine’s Day Cupcakes

: Chocolate Chocolate Cupcakes

: Cookies & Cream Cupcakes

: Shaun the Sheep Cupcakes

: Funfetti Cupcakes

: Funfetti Cupcakes

: Cowboy Cupcakes w/ Chocolate Hats & Boots

MACARONS

All of our Macarons are Gluten Free

: Matcha Macarons

: Coffee Macarons

: Cookie Dough Macarons

: Vanilla Macarons

: Lemon Macarons

: Cinnamon Macarons

: Pistachio Macarons

BROWNIES & BARS

: Passionfruit Bars

: S’Mores Cookie Bars

: Flourless Fudgy Brownies

: Snickers Squares

: Buckeye Brownies

: Lemon Bars

: Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb Bars

: Raspberry Crumb Cake Bars

PIES, CRISPS & CRUMBLES

: Peanut Butter Cup Pie

: Brown Sugar Sweet Potato Pie

: Banana Cream Pie

: Maple Pecan Pie

: Pumpkin Pie

: Peach Blueberry Pie

: Flag Berry Pie

: Cinnamon Apple Pear Crisp

: Apple Hand Pies

: Whoopie Pies

: Pecan Pie

: Caramel Apple Pie

: Plum Torte

: Peach Blueberry Crisp

: Gobbler Sweet Potato Pie

LOAVES

: Chocolate Walnut Povitica

: Chocolate Babka

: Chocolate Chip Banana Zucchini Bread

: Iced Lemon Loaf

: Strawberry Banana Bread

: Marble Pound Cake

: Pumpkin Spice Babka

BREADS

: Challah

: Raspberry Star Bread

: Cranberry Nut Bread

: Everything Bagels

: Rustic Bread

: Challah

: Soft Pretzels

: Menorah Challah

FUDGE

: Oreo Fudge

: Turtle Fudge

: Gingerbread Swirl Fudge

: Cake Batter Fudge

: Pecan Gingerbread Fudge

FROZEN TREATS

: Melon Basil Sorbet

: Dragronfruit Sorbet

SWEET CONFECTIONS

: Peanut Butter Oreo Bark

: Eggless Cookie Dough

: Chocolate Boots & Horseshoes

GLUTEN FREE

: Chocolate Fudge Cake

: Buttercream Rose Cake

: Flourless Lemon Almond Cake

: Maple Pecan Pie

: Flourless Fudgy Brownies

: Almond Joy Macaroons

: Coconut Macaroons

: Chocolate Crinkle Cookies

: Turtle Fudge

: French Macarons

Gifts & Events

: French Macarons

: Peanutella

: Cashew Macademia Nut Funfetti Butter

: Dipped Pretzels

: Oreo Truffles

Baking Order Request Form